VIDEO GAME EDITION!
Similar to previous Rapid Fire posts, I'll be looking at three albums (or in this case, soundtracks) and briefly discussing them before giving them a rating and highlighting tracks that I thought stood out.
The three video game soundtracks I'll be looking at do share certain aspects. For starters, they're all from 3D platformers and they're all relatively recent releases (two came out this year). However, the musical style for each soundtrack is unique enough to warrant their choices for this post, in my opinion. Apologies if you're not into video game music but you might get some joy out of these soundtracks, if you can find them.
1. Tearaway Unfolded - Brian D'Oliveira and Kenneth Young
Tearaway Unfolded is probably one of my favourite platformers ever and if it weren't for A Hat In Time, it'd be my favourite platformer of the last decade (even if it is technically an adaptation/remake). It contains some amazing platforming segments unlike any other in video game history and brings out the creativity through innovative ways. Thankfully, the soundtrack is equally unique for a video game and doesn't fall into the trap of being too much like Mario, nor does it try to be grand like Skyrim. It's whimsical and at times a bit clunky but it works perfectly in the game.
There's a clear difference between the tracks composed by Kenneth Young and the ones by Brian D'Oliveira. Young tends to be responsible for the tunes that are more jovial and quaint, such as the first tune "The Hole In The Sky" or "Cutting Mat" and its variants whereas D'Oliveira is best at the harsher sounding, more dissonant pieces such as "The Barn" and "Scraps" (again, along with its variants). However, occasionally the two work together to give us some of the game's iconic tracks such as "Gibbet Hill Pilgrimage" or individually choose to blend styles to give us excellent pieces like "The Orchards" or techno-Folk track "Between The Pages, Page Two".
It's hard to accurately describe without getting stuck into the soundtrack (and game) yourself but the great thing about the soundtrack is the bizarre yet soothing nature to it. It's the musical equivalent of a claymation cottage with a roaring fire in a Tim Burtonesque forest landscape; quaint but with a hint of kookiness. It also doesn't fall into the trap of trying so hard to be weird that it forgets to be good. Many tracks are catchy and cute, just like the game itself, but overall the soundtrack for Tearaway Unfolded is delightful. It's not your typical sweeping Disney-lite score or epic World Of Warcraft feast, it's something eclectic and special for fans of the genre.
1. The Hole In The Sky
2. Scraps
2. Scraps
3. Cutting Mat #1
4. Green Man Groove
5. The Orchards
6. The Squirrel Village
7. Renaissance Hop (Record Scratching Tune)
8. Pig Riding
9. St. Swithin's Moor
10. St. Swithin's Moor, Corvus Hexus
11. St. Swithin's Moor, Scraps
12. St. Swithin's Moor, The Big Tree
13. Enter The Barn
14. Rollin'
15. The Barn
16. Shouty Orange Head
17. Cutting Mat #2
18. Gibbet Hill Intro, Lament & Hornpipe
19. Gibbet Hill Pilgrimage
20. Gibbet Hill Scraps
21. Gibbet Hill Processional
22. Sogport Scraps
23. The Baby Wendigo
24. Squirrels & Scraps
25. Cutting Mat #3
26. Beach Bum
27. Heartless Reel
28. The Tavern
29. Wendigo Fissure
30. Elevate This
31. Gopher It
32. The Gopher
33. The Lab
34. The Lab Tick Tock
35. The Lab Scraps
36. The Caverns Scraps
37. The Caverns Scraps Chase
38. Scraps Crazy
39. Cutting Mat #4, Scraps
40. Scraps Reformed
41. Between The Pages, Page One
42. Between The Pages, Page Two
43. Desert Of The Mind
44. Desert Pig Ride
45. Desert Plane Ride
46. The Mislaid Message
47. The Tear
48. The You
49. Is This Goodbye
50. The Message
ALBUM RATING - 7/10
Next up is a platformer that everyone's saying was a disappointment even though people loved it when it came out.
2. Yooka-Laylee - Steve Burke, Grant Kirkhope and David Wise
Similar to the previous soundtrack, the duty of composing the music wasn't just given to one artist. Composers from a collection of classic Nintendo platformers were brought in to give the game that classic N64 feel; Grant Kirkhope provided music for levels, Steve Burke for multiplayer games and David Wise for minecart levels with each of them trying their hand at boss battle themes too. Whilst each artist brings their own specific flair to appropriate tracks, this can work against the illusion of creating a nostalgia fest.
Older games usually stuck with one main composer so the classic N64 or PS1 games often had their own signature sound. The problem with a modern game designed to evoke memories and feelings experienced when playing those classics BUT with multiple composers is that you're never really going to become fully immersed in the memory. One moment, you'll be back in your old living room running around in Banjo Kazooie as you listen to Kirkhope's marimba filled Tribalstack Tropics (or "World 1 Theme" as it's called on the soundtrack to avoid spoilers), the next you'll be riding a minecart listening to one of David Wise's minecart themes that sounds noticeably different, as if it's from a completely different game...because it is! It's from Donkey Kong Country.
As far as the soundtrack goes, it needed to be more consistent to truly achieve its goal. I appreciate that they tried to achieve this by giving different composers different responsibilities and I don't want to give you the wrong idea about the quality of the music; it's well crafted and aside from a few annoying multiplayer game themes, every song is catchy enough to keep you entertained as you play. However, as bad as this sounds, I almost feel like the soundtrack needed less variety. If you wanted a soundtrack that combines elements of the past with modern platforming innovations, this would've been the way to go. Unfortunately, the gameplay doesn't quite go that far so in the end, it doesn't quite work as well as I wished it had.
Older games usually stuck with one main composer so the classic N64 or PS1 games often had their own signature sound. The problem with a modern game designed to evoke memories and feelings experienced when playing those classics BUT with multiple composers is that you're never really going to become fully immersed in the memory. One moment, you'll be back in your old living room running around in Banjo Kazooie as you listen to Kirkhope's marimba filled Tribalstack Tropics (or "World 1 Theme" as it's called on the soundtrack to avoid spoilers), the next you'll be riding a minecart listening to one of David Wise's minecart themes that sounds noticeably different, as if it's from a completely different game...because it is! It's from Donkey Kong Country.
As far as the soundtrack goes, it needed to be more consistent to truly achieve its goal. I appreciate that they tried to achieve this by giving different composers different responsibilities and I don't want to give you the wrong idea about the quality of the music; it's well crafted and aside from a few annoying multiplayer game themes, every song is catchy enough to keep you entertained as you play. However, as bad as this sounds, I almost feel like the soundtrack needed less variety. If you wanted a soundtrack that combines elements of the past with modern platforming innovations, this would've been the way to go. Unfortunately, the gameplay doesn't quite go that far so in the end, it doesn't quite work as well as I wished it had.
1. Main Theme
2. Shipwreck Creek
3. Hivory Towers
4. World 1 Theme
5. World 2 Theme
6. World 3 Theme
7. World 4 Theme
8. World 5 Theme
9. Uphill Battle
10. Frosty Fray
11. Armed And Dangerous
12. Track Attack
13. Skiffy Skirmish
14. Final Beeting
15. Kartos Karting
16. Bee Bop
17. Hurdle Hijinx
18. Up 'N' Nova
19. Jobstacle Course
20. Glaciators
21. Blag The Flag
22. Gun-tlet Run
23. Minecart Theme (World 1)
24. Minecart Theme (World 2)
25. Minecart Theme (World 3)
26. Minecart Theme (World 4)
27. Minecart Theme (World 5)
28. Tropic Trials
29. World 1 Variant #1
30. World 1 Variant #2
31. World 2 Variant #1
32. World 2 Variant #2
33. World 3 Variant #1
34. World 3 Variant #2
35. World 4 Variant #1
36. World 4 Variant #2
37. World 5 Variant #1
38. World 5 Variant #2
ALBUM RATING - 6/10
Finally, we have a soundtrack from a game released to critical acclaim just a couple of months ago. It also contains a specially written song as its main theme and I hate it.
3. Super Mario Odyssey - Naoto Kubo, Shiho Fuji and Koji Kondo
Super Mario Odyssey is probably the most ambitious Mario platformer since Sunshine but sadly contains the least ambitious soundtrack since the DS game that basically ripped off "Gusty Garden Galaxy" for one of their levels. It's a collection of generic orchestra music that sounds decent in the levels but holds up poorly outside of the game, something that can't be said for the previous two albums I've looked at in this post...or indeed any video game soundtrack I've written about in length on the blog before. It has the basics covered (each level has its distinct theme, the first proper level has a grand feel to convey exploration, yada yada yada) but to me, it makes one crucial mistake.
When I think of Mario platformers of the past, I can always think of at least one specific tune that stands out and acts as a kind of representative of the game. More often than not it's the game's main theme or hub world music but occasionally it's from a level. Super Mario 64 has "Bob-Omb Battlefield", Super Mario Sunshine has "Delfino Plaza" and Super Mario Galaxy has the aforementioned "Gusty Garden Galaxy". Super Mario Odyssey doesn't have that instantly iconic level theme. The closest it has is the "Steam Gardens" music but even that doesn't grab you in the same way previous tunes do; if anything, it's notable for sounding like music from a series other than Mario. That's about it.
However, what the game DOES have is its own song with lyrics and everything. "Jump Up, Super Star!" or, as it's called on the soundtrack, "NDC Festival". This is the song that's used in the game's opening menu and in all the fucking promotional material for the game, emphasis on "promotion". I hate this song because I don't hear a colourful piece of video game music; I hear manufactured, soulless advertising in the guise of a song. The music's alright but when lyrics contain lines like "It's freedom like you never knew" and "I'm flipping the switch" that sound like they're trying to push a product instead of entertain gamers, the catchy tune doesn't mean shit.
There are a couple of decent tracks in this game but everything else just kind of blends into the scenery. Even 8-bit remixes of each level fall flat because...well, it's fucking 8-bit. It sounds like crap compared to a fully orchestrated score (although the concept is still neat). Iconic music has been replaced by undeniable corporate box-ticking, although the game is great so I guess it must have worked on me in some level. That doesn't stop me from pointing out how weak the soundtrack is compared to the last couple of proper 3D Mario platformers that also used an orchestra but had the benefit of being led by Koji Kondo, a much superior composer to Naoto Kubo.
1. Bonneton
2. Fossil Falls
3. Fossil Falls (8-Bit)
4. Fossil Falls: Dinosaur
5. Tostarena: Ruins
6. Tosatarena: Ruins (8-Bit)
7. Tostarena: Night
8. Tostarena: Night (8-Bit)
9. Tostarena: Town
10. Tostarena: Jaxi
11. Steam Gardens
12. Steam Gardens (8-Bit)
13. Steam Gardens: Sherm
14. Lake Lamode 1
15. Lake Lamode 1 (8-Bit)
16. Lake Lamode 2
17. Lake Lamode: Underwater Passage
18. Forgotten Isle 1
19. Forgotten Isle 2
20. Forgotten Isle 2 (8-Bit)
21. New Donk City: Night 1
22. New Donk City: Night 2
23. New Donk City: Daytime
24. New Donk City: Cafe
25. New Donk City (Band Performance)
26. NDC Festival
27. NDC Festival (Japanese)
28. NDC Festival (8-Bit)
29. Bubblaine
30. Bubblaine: Underwater
31. Bubblaine (8-Bit)
32. Shiveria: Town
33. Shiveria: Race Course Entrance
34. Mount Volbono
35. Mount Volbono (8-Bit)
36. Mount Volbono: Town
37. Bowser's Castle 1
38. Bowser's Castle 1 (8-Bit)
39. Bowser's Castle 2
40. Honeylune Ridge
41. Honeylune Ridge (8-Bit)
42. Honeylune Ridge: Caves
43. Honeylune Ridge: Wedding Hall
44. Honeylune Ridge: Collapse
45. Honeylune Ridge: Collapse (8-Bit)
46. Honeylune Ridge: Escape
47. Honeylune Ridge: Escape (Japanese)
48. Honeylune Ridge: Escape (8-Bit)
49. Peach's Castle
50. Broodals Battle
51. Madame Broode Battle
52. Knucklotec Battle
53. Torkdrift Battle
54. Mechawiggler Battle
55. Mollusque-Lanceur Battle
56. Mollusque-Lanceur Battle (8-Bit)
57. Cookatiel Battle
58. Ruined Dragon Battle
59. RoboBrood Battle
60. Bowser Battle 1
61. Bowser Battle 2
62. Run, Jump, Throw! 1
63. Run, Jump, Throw! 2
64. Run, Jump, Throw! 2 (8-Bit)
65. Subterranean 1
66. Subterranean 1 (8-Bit)
67. Subterranean 2
68. Caves
69. Ice
70. Another World
71. Ruins
72. Ruins (8-Bit)
73. Projection Room (Above Ground)
74. Projection Room (Underground)
75. Above The Clouds
76. Toad Brigade Member
77. To The Next Kingdom
78. Shop
79. Race
80. RC Car
81. Spinning Slots
82. Climactic Duel!
83. Staff Roll
ALBUM RATING - 5/10
Jesus, that was a pain to type out. The next blog post won't be so long or arduous on the scroll bar!
No comments:
Post a Comment